We have a consistant bedtime routine that begins around 8:30 each night. We have a sugar-free snack, bath, and books. He goes to sleep (alone) very easily but wakes in a few hours usually screaming. We have tried to let him "self soothe" with no success. Several nights a week this turns into 2-3 hour panic stricken episode. Our peditrican shruggs it off and says he will outgrow it but is causes huge problems with waking our 5 month old who sleeps great. We have tried all kinds of white noise and even calmling music with no luck.
He was a premature infant and a very sick baby—wondering if any of this could contribute to his sleeping problems???
Open to any suggestions but trying to avoid any medications to help him sleep
Man, that's hard isn't it?
Have you thought about making his bed-time earlier? I know it sounds counter-intuitive, but sometimes it works. Try 20 minutes earlier or even 40 (sleep cycles work in 20 minute increments) and see how he does?
How much is he sleeping per 24 hours? I think 2 year olds need around 13 hours of sleep total (I can't remember for sure; I'll look it up and edit if necessary) If his nap is wonky it can affect his night time sleep. ***ETA: 2 year olds need 11-12 hours at night and a nap of 1-2 hours, so 12-14 hours total. So 13 is an average.***
Last, have you checked out _The No-Cry Sleep Solution for Toddlers_ by Elizabeth Pantley? I used some of her tips and techniques for my daughter and though it took a little while, we saw great results.
Good luck, you have my empathy!